Fixing the BROKEN FOURTH BRANCH

In recent years there has been much commentary about how the three branches of our government are “broken.”  The media itself has reported that, no matter the political point of view, most voters are tired of the inability of government to function effectively, and solve the nation’s problems.  Citizens have also become “media skeptics.”  This has clearly come into focus during some of the Republican debates when moderators underperformed, and consequently did not meet their responsibilities within the important role media has in our democracy.  

The Media has often been called the "Fourth Branch of Government."  When the other three branches of government can't or won't come forward with the truth, the Media often has.   This “honesty” mechanism was designed into the US Constitution by the writers.  

James Madison said, “A popular government without popular information or the means of acquiring it is but a prologue to a farce, or a tragedy, or perhaps both.”  If George Washington is considered father of our nation, then James Madison is regarded as father of the constitution, and he was the First Amendment author.

It’s time for the media to REMEMBER its important role.  The media has a professional and patriotic duty to not be biased.  Second only to when citizens use their right to vote, the Media has the ability to keep our democracy safe, and change history in America.  

The media is critical to keeping our government honest, and in helping us elect and refresh government through our right to vote.  In the exercise of their personal First Amendment  rights, when journalists and commentators are expressing an opinion, they should clearly declare their bias.  Otherwise, they, or media outlets and sources, should remain unbiased and dedicated to fulfilling their important role in our democracy.

WHAT THE MEDIA SHOULD DO TO FULFILL THEIR ROLE?

• Publish only what candidates say about THEMSELVES.  See Voting Alert Beacon #3.
• Don't publish what they say about OTHERS.  See Voting Alert Beacon #3.
• Publish regular reports of candidate campaign contributions, and positively highlight the small contributions while negatively highlighting large contributions.  Especially, shine a negative highlight on pacts, special interests, and other "non-human" contributions.  See Voting Alert Beacon #5.
• On interview programs, invite only regular citizens for comment, not political pundits or commentators.
• Stop taking and publishing polls.  See Voting Alert Beacon #4.

SHOULD NOT DO

Media SHOULD NOT endorse candidates or take positions on the issues.  If and when they do, they change from fulfilling their special role and responsibility as the “Fourth Branch of Government” to becoming JUST ANOTHER SPECIAL INTEREST.

Honesty and public service are the gears that drive our democracy, and we turn those gears with our RIGHT TO VOTE.   LET’S ALL VOTE!

. . .  remember that America’s best days aren’t behind her.   America’s best days are ahead of her.  They always have been and always will be.

Dave

Copyright © 2015 by David William Wygant. All rights reserved.  

GET OFF THE BANDWAGON TO VOTE

What is a bandwagon?

As we do so often these days, I took the question to “Mr./Ms. Google Search.”  Because most of us view Merriam-Webster as a reliable dictionary, I picked that response.

Merriam-Webster says that a “bandwagon” is: 1)  a usually ornate and high wagon for a band of musicians, especially in a circus parade, 2)  a popular party, faction, or cause that attracts growing support —often used in such phrases as jump on the bandwagon, or 3)  a popular activity, effort, cause, etc., that attracts growing support. 

Honestly, I could see any or all of the Merriam-Webster elements defining a political campaign and/or a political party.  I’m not saying this is good or bad.  I’ll let you pick one for yourself.  

Ok, why did I just type all of that?

Well, in a campaign of any kind (anywhere) the people who own the bandwagon want you to get on theirs.  In a political campaign for elective office, this means that they want you to vote for them — while you’re on the bandwagon.  Their ultimate goal would be to get everyone on their bandwagon, and keep them there.  Of course, in reality there are other bandwagons, and people get on all of them.  

Well, not everyone actually.  In America, we have two major parties.  While, a lot of people get on those wagons, there’s another group called “independents.”  They don’t get on anyone’s wagon.  Or, if they do, they switch back and forth frequently.  Quite often they cast their votes while not on anyone's bandwagon, but while they are standing on solid ground.  They can teach us something!

Here’s part of the lesson.  Voting Alert Beacon #7 - In Secret, tells us to keep our vote(s) a secret.  In effect, it says, “Ride a bandwagon if you want, but get off the wagon to cast your vote.”  In a perfect world, the bandwagons might carry the information and messaging, but we would all get off the wagon to vote while standing on solid ground like the independents always have.  Alas, many people vote while they are standing on someone’s wagon, and they declare (brag) what they’ve done to pollsters.

DO THIS:  All of us always need to vote, and thusly exercise/preserve our RIGHT TO VOTE, but within the right, there’s something else.  We need to vote independently.  Independent in the sense of using our own mind (thoughts) and heart (conscience) to decide.  It is this independence that gives our vote the POWER it is capable of generating.

VOTE IN SECRET!  TELL NO ONE!

Honesty and public service are the gears that drive our democracy, and we turn those gears with our RIGHT TO VOTE.   LET’S ALL VOTE!

. . .  remember that America’s best days aren’t behind her.   America’s best days are ahead of her.  They always have been and always will be.

Dave

Copyright © 2015 by David William Wygant. All rights reserved.  

SCORING THE FIRST DEBATE

The first Presidential debate of the 2016 campaign season is hosted by Fox News.  It will be in Cleveland, Ohio on August 6th, beginning at 5:00pm ET.  Only two more days!  

For this first Republican debate, the good news is that finally all of the candidates will be in one spot, making it easier for we Voters to gauge their experience and capability.  By-the-way, it is also good news that there are so many of them.  Hopefully, more will become Democratic candidates soon.  Having a wide selection of opinions and personalities is good for the country, and makes our job as Voters more interesting.  

The bad news is that it could get noisy.  Will the candidates talk about the issues we’re interested in?  Look for candidates that seem to have we Voters in mind.  Or, will the debate devolve into a discussion that they’re having with themselves?  Look for candidates that directly talk to us.

First remember: Voting Alert Beacon #3:  Listen/Ignore

This is a great opportunity to “listen” to positive candidates and “ignore” negative candidates.  Before the debate, take a moment to review Beacon #3, but the gist of it is that we should listen intently to those candidates who talk only about their leadership ability, experience and position (plan) on the issues.  Just as intently, we should ignore candidates that talk about the other candidates “stuff.”  

For the debate, create a scorecard with two boxes next to each candidate’s name.  Label the boxes as Listen and Ignore.  When a candidate talks only about their stuff, put a check mark in the Listen box.  If they talk about the other candidates stuff put a check mark in the Ignore box.  When they make negative comments of any kind about the other candidate (s), that should also earn them an Ignore checkmark.  

Then after the debate, for each candidate, subtract the number of check marks in the Ignore box from the number of check marks in the Listen box.  Presto, you have the score for each candidate.  Lastly, see who has the largest score, and then think about how you feel about their positions on the issues.

Second remember:  Voter Alert Beacon #7:  Keep It A Secret

Now your done.  You watched the debate.  You kept score using Beacon #3.  You have a candidate high score, and you’re thinking about what they said about the issues.  Keep all of your scoring, and your thoughts or feelings secret.  They belong to only you!  As long as they are your secret, they are powerful, and your vote will be.

Third remember:  Voter Alert Beacon #4:  Polls

Talk with your friends.  Discuss the issues.  Combine information and all learn together.  Just be sure you don’t respond to candidates, media, or organizations who are conducting polls and want your opinion.  If you respond, you lessen your power as a voter, and of your vote directly.

Honesty and public service are the gears that drive our democracy, and we turn those gears with our RIGHT TO VOTE.   LET’S ALL VOTE!

. . .  remember that America’s best days aren’t behind her.   America’s best days are ahead of her.  They always have been and always will be.

Dave

Copyright © 2015 by David William Wygant. All rights reserved.  

TALE OF TWO POLLS

A Virtuous Circle of Activity

The first poll is conducted by business to understand what products and services we need.  Then, they are able to create the products and services we want.  While the process can vary, it often begins with customer research which uncovers unmet needs.  Then a vision for how the need might innovatively and profitably be met emerges, followed by actions and activities that lead to the creation of the product or service.  Our lives are further enriched, and business makes the profit it needs to employ people,  build more products and services, and pay taxes.  A virtuous circle of activity.

A Negative Feedback Loop Is Created

The second poll is used by politicians to build positions on the issues that will insure they are elected or re-elected.  Some of the negative consequences include the following:

• Polls divide us against ourselves as citizens and voters.
• Polls lessen our independent thinking by creating a bandwagon for us to jump onto.  
• Polls are used to design and measure the effectiveness of negative advertising.  As a result, the advertising becomes more negative and more personal.  
• Polls determine the issues and “talking points of the day.”  The connection between what needs to be discussed and what is discussed becomes weaker and weaker.
• Polls are used to “keep score” between candidates and negatively reinforce the arguments they have with each other.  The campaigns become louder and more negative, and eventually reach a point where we voters are no longer part of the discussion.

A negative feedback loop is created that excludes independent thought, leadership, and new ideas, while serving to suppress honesty and genuine public service.

PLEASE FOLLOW VOTING ALERT BEACON #4:  POLLS

Stop giving and participating in political polls and focus groups taken by the candidates.  Let’s make America a poll dead zone. When we stop telling the politicians what we think, then maybe, we’ll find out what they think.  The only questions that should be answered by anyone, are the questions we voters ask the candidates.  Then we can decide what we think, and vote powerfully and effectively.  

Honesty and public service are the gears that drive our democracy, and we turn those gears with our RIGHT TO VOTE.   LET’S ALL VOTE!

. . .  remember that America’s best days aren’t behind her.   America’s best days are ahead of her.  They always have been and always will be.

Dave

Copyright © 2015 by David William Wygant. All rights reserved.  

Minnesota Primary Results

Yesterday, August 12th, 2014, the Minnesota primary election was held.  Current reporting is indicating that only slightly less than 10% of the eligible voters cast a vote.  According to predictions, this seems to be what everyone expected.  The reasons given are classic:  Midterm election, Disinterest or disgust in politics generally, or maybe in Minnesota we’re doing pretty well according to some.  For better or for worst, depending on your point of view, the budget is in balance at the moment, and our unemployment rate is generally low.  Of course, if you don’t have a job, you wouldn’t consider pretty low as good enough.  Nonetheless, and in any event, the primary election results are now in.

Let’s look closely at the statewide races.  This year in Minnesota the statewide top of the ticket race for Governor is between Mark Dayton (incumbent-Democrat) and Jeff Johnson (challenger-Republican).  The race for U.S. Senator from Minnesota is between Al Franken (incumbent-Democrat) and Michael McFadden (challenger-Republican).  Now the candidates reset their clocks and begin campaigning to win the election in November.

It’s also time for we voters to reset our clocks and watch what the candidates do next.  Let’s get into the habit of using the Voting Alert Beacons.  We can start with the core Beacons:  Beacon #3:  Listen/Ignore, Beacon #4: The Polls, and Beacon #5:  The Money.

Beacon #3:  Listen/Ignore

Go back to the Voting Alert Beacons blog and review the detail of this step.  At its core is that we want to only listen to what the candidate says about themselves, their positions on the issues and what they plan to do.  Ignore everything else they say.  To begin, check the candidate’s websites.

Mark Dayton

Jeff Johnson

Al Franken

Michael McFadden

Beacon #4:  The Polls

This is about what you shouldn’t do.  I know that sounds negative, but it’s important not to read polls and not to participate.  When a candidate’s representative call you, a polling company appears, or the media interrupts your day, just say no.

Beacon #5:  The Money

Let’s start with the numbers as of the end of July (see below).  This information comes from the Federal Election Committee and from the state of Minnesota.  Generally, it’s what we might expect (not saying this is OK).  The incumbent has a lot more money in total and they have a lot more money from PACs and special interests.  Again, review Beacon #5 and remember the ideal candidate won’t take money from special interest groups and only smaller amounts from individuals.

Minnesota Governor Candidates

Mark Dayton

Individual  $549,437.07

Lobbyists  $11,540.00

PACs  $41,446.86

Jeff Johnson

Individual  $204,640.29

Lobbyists  $2,898.40

PACs  $1,050.00

Minnesota Senate Candidates

Al Franken

Individual  $12,442,034.00

PAC  $1,003,139.00

Candidate  $0.00

Other  $1,680,395.00

Michael McFadden

Individual  $3,147,166.00

PAC  $249,500.00

Candidate  $5,200.00

Other  $2,448.00

NOTE:  There is a lot more money in the senate race because contributors (individual and special interest) from all over the country send money.  Human nature being what it is, the result is that whoever our Senator is really doesn’t faithfully represent Minnesota, as they should.

OK, VOTERS, let’s get to work.  Let’s get ready to vote in November by following the Voting Alert Beacons along the way.

Spread the word!  Tell your friends about the Voting Alert Beacons!

. . .  remember that America’s best days aren’t behind her.   America’s best days are ahead of her.  They always have been and always will be.

Dave

Copyright © 2014 by David William Wygant. All rights reserved.  

OUR “CALL TO DUTY” AS VOTERS IS RINGING NOW

It’s already started.  

We’re now fully immersed in the 2014 election cycle.  Parties and politicians are throwing mud with both hands.  Instead, wouldn’t it be refreshing if party or person were to spend their time and energy offering positive solutions, and a little simple honesty?  Everyone spends too much time talking about what’s wrong with the “other” position or person, and not enough time on what they will do to solve problems if they get a chance.

It’s time for we voters to begin practicing our listening skills.  Voting Alert Beacon #3 (Listen / Ignore) offers a simple approach that will help us decide who to vote for.  LISTEN to what candidates say about themselves and their positions on the issues.  IGNORE what they say about their opponents and their opponent's positions on the issues.

Another feature of election cycles that adds energy to the “mud-slinging” is the opinion poll.  Have you ever noticed how there’s an opinion poll for everything?  Polls enable the candidates to take positions for the sole purpose of gaining our votes.  They allow the parties and persons to do what they think enough voters want them to do so they can win the election. 

When you get that telephone call, you hear a knock on the door, or someone stops you on the street, just say “no.”  Voting Alert Beacon #4 (The Polls) is simple and clear on what we need to do.  DO NOT participate in polls except the National Census every ten years. Poll driven positions on the issues would cease to exist, and the candidates would be pushed toward thoughtful consideration of what they need to do and what should be done.

A final area for voters to keep a close eye on throughout the 2014 election cycle, and after when our elected public servants begin to work, is in problem solving and solution finding.  History shows us that sometimes they try to fix things that aren’t broken, or they do it in a way that breaks what was working pretty well, while increasing the size and seriousness of the original problem.  As a result, costs go up and the government grows larger.

Remember, Listen / Ignore and Just Say No!

. . .  remember that America’s best days aren’t behind her.   America’s best days are ahead of her.  They always have been and always will be.

Dave

Copyright © 2014 by David William Wygant. All rights reserved. 

Happy Flag Day Everyone!

This morning I was reading some news accounts and predications about speeches that candidates Obama and Romney are giving in Ohio.  All of the “political predictors of the future” are guessing about what each may say.  While I’m hopeful, I have doubts that either will talk about something that is close to a vision for success.  Tomorrow, if I’m wrong and there is something exciting to write about, I certainly will.

Today, I’d like to write about our most precious right.  The right to vote.  Especially, since it’s Flag Day, and I feel patriotic.

Actually, I don’t have much to write, but I do have some questions for us to think about.

Voting Alert Beacon #4

• There are so many polls taken during the election season.  What if everyone refused to participate?  What if we told the pollsters it was none of the business (See Voting Alert Beacon #7)?
• How would the candidates create their positions?
• How would the candidates create the negative marketing ads?
• Would this new kind of “blindness” caused by the lack of polling information cause them to look inward to their own personal beliefs and visions?
• Would they then have to talk to us about where THEY think we should go, and where they want to lead us?

Voting Alert Beacon #6

• What if everyone voted, literally?
• Doesn’t it make sense that increased numbers of citizens voting would help us make better choices as a country?  Do you ever wonder about all the people who don’t vote regularly because they’re just discouraged, and how many of them are really creative and smart?  What if we had that valuable input?
• Some people would like to vote, but they don’t have a way to the polls.  You know, no car or they’re physically handicapped.  Why can’t all of us who are blessed just make sure everyone in sight has a way to the polling places to vote?
• If voting is so important to a democracy, why don’t we get citations or tickets when you don’t?  We can get a ticket for speeding, right?  Of course, because we are a free people, we have a right NOT to vote, don’t we?  No, let’s not mess with that.

Voting Alert Beacon #7

• What would be the effect on candidates and the “race for office” if no one knew how we voters were going to vote?  Really, what if they had no idea?
• Would the value of our individual votes go up?
• Would candidates spend as much time criticizing their opponents?
• Or, would they talk more about what they want to accomplish and why we should vote for them?
• Oh, what about the special interests?  What if the unions, the professional associations, and lobbying groups we belonged to had no idea how we were going to vote?  Many of these special interest groups give voice to important concerns, but do they have a right to knowledge about how we will vote?
• Come to think about it, does anybody or anything have a right to influencing, controlling or knowing about our vote? 

What if everyone who is eligible to vote cast a vote, and what if they were all cast in total secrecy?  Sounds exciting, doesn’t it?

Hey, sorry for all the questions!  I was just practicing how to be a thinking voter!

Again, Happy Flag Day!


. . .  remember that America’s best days aren’t behind her.   America’s best days are ahead of her.  They always have been and always will be.

Dave

Copyright © 2012 by David William Wygant. All rights reserved.